Cam vs twins
#1
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: fredericksburg, virginia
Posts: 3,465
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Cam vs twins
Both are going to provide more air and improve drivability. It just seems to me on a dozen or so recent threads that when people want to lower egts on their rigs the suggestion is always twins and never a cam.
So for the many overfueled trucks in dtr- wouldn't an aftermarket cam be a viable solution for lower egts and be less costly than adding a second turbo?? In some cases it might even be cheaper than an aftermaket turbo in the first place. It seems like most the guys running cams have twins already.
Is the cam a good alternative to twins, especially for guys not looking for stupid power? Am I correct in thinking cams are an overlooked bomb? Especially since a cam can help solve the lift pump probem,....
Just something I've been pondering for the last month or so
So for the many overfueled trucks in dtr- wouldn't an aftermarket cam be a viable solution for lower egts and be less costly than adding a second turbo?? In some cases it might even be cheaper than an aftermaket turbo in the first place. It seems like most the guys running cams have twins already.
Is the cam a good alternative to twins, especially for guys not looking for stupid power? Am I correct in thinking cams are an overlooked bomb? Especially since a cam can help solve the lift pump probem,....
Just something I've been pondering for the last month or so
#4
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Southern, Indiana
Posts: 5,352
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Cams are overlooked because they dont offer that 5 minute instant power like a fueling box or a new set of twins can offer.
Also a cam is some serious work.
To me its a no brainer; a cam is part of the performance puzzle that many over look.
There are many different cams out there to choose from but any of the 3 (or more from F1) seem to fit most needs.
Valve springs are also overlooked because most dont have any idea on how to install them and there isnt that "instant power gain". But even springs by themselves will increase your horsepower indirectly and make your engine function properly.
Overall hp gain and egt decrease twins are great. But with the boost pressure increase from twins that puts you back at needing springs...
Pieces of the puzzle guys.
If you want to hear some valve float (about a seconds worth) from a high boosted 2001 24V watch the video in my sig. The 2nd truck is mine and there is not float with the same rpm.
Sorry if I sidetracked the thread in any way.
The burgundy 01 in the video dynoed 621rwhp on a single turbo on diesel only on David's Dunbars dyno....its probably getting a cam/springs this winter.
Also a cam is some serious work.
To me its a no brainer; a cam is part of the performance puzzle that many over look.
There are many different cams out there to choose from but any of the 3 (or more from F1) seem to fit most needs.
Valve springs are also overlooked because most dont have any idea on how to install them and there isnt that "instant power gain". But even springs by themselves will increase your horsepower indirectly and make your engine function properly.
Overall hp gain and egt decrease twins are great. But with the boost pressure increase from twins that puts you back at needing springs...
Pieces of the puzzle guys.
If you want to hear some valve float (about a seconds worth) from a high boosted 2001 24V watch the video in my sig. The 2nd truck is mine and there is not float with the same rpm.
Sorry if I sidetracked the thread in any way.
The burgundy 01 in the video dynoed 621rwhp on a single turbo on diesel only on David's Dunbars dyno....its probably getting a cam/springs this winter.
#5
A cam would be a great addition to anybodies truck who was looking to lower EGT's and seriously improve spool up. People as a rule probably don't look into the cam option as quick because it's not a 'horsepower' adder. I will say this - my Helix 2 is a horsepower extender. With that cam she digs on into the redline and wants more.
#6
Registered User
Good points.
Will a cam reduce EGT's as well? (never mind, we posted at the same time).
Will a cam reduce EGT's as well? (never mind, we posted at the same time).
Last edited by Marine; 09-28-2006 at 07:47 AM. Reason: posted the answer to my question at the same time.
Trending Topics
#9
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Southern, Indiana
Posts: 5,352
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
how would a big cam affect driveability with a stock turbo?
#10
Registered User
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Jeffersonville, Ohio
Posts: 3,604
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Actually, I'll bet you could push that stock charger to a bit more power before EGT's got crazy. Remember, it's not about boost, but AIRFLOW. The cam helps get more airflow.
Now, if you're pushing your stocker to 45psi, the cam won't help much on the stocker. If you keep the turbo in it's efficient range, EGT's should go down!
Chris
Now, if you're pushing your stocker to 45psi, the cam won't help much on the stocker. If you keep the turbo in it's efficient range, EGT's should go down!
Chris
#12
Registered User
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Jeffersonville, Ohio
Posts: 3,604
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Maybe...HOHN seems to think so! Peronally, since you have to buy a Dodgezilla anyway, I'd go with a BD Super B. That little charger has impressed me
Chris
Chris
#13
Registered User
the BD is an S300, correct? From what I understand, the S300 will give me more top end power, lower EGT's, but will have more bottom end lag. I want the better bottom end for towing, and the EGT's wont be that big of a difference between the 2.
The Dodgezilla is also about 500.00 cheaper.
The Dodgezilla is also about 500.00 cheaper.
Last edited by Marine; 09-28-2006 at 08:27 AM. Reason: price
#14
Registered User
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Jeffersonville, Ohio
Posts: 3,604
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The Super B is an S200/S300 hybrid...smaller compressor wheel, a "bit" bigger exhaust side than a Dodgezilla!
I'll bet the spool is about the same, and the Super B runs better on the top end, and is a tougher turbo to boot! The Super B's really spool well for the way they cool!
I have a thing against Holsets...I hurt them too easily
I'll bet the spool is about the same, and the Super B runs better on the top end, and is a tougher turbo to boot! The Super B's really spool well for the way they cool!
I have a thing against Holsets...I hurt them too easily