Stamey

Who makes the best Oxy-Acetylene torch outfit? My Dad has Smith, and says they are the best. I see a lot of "Victor" out there though.
Whose is best?
Is the Victor worth a darn?


Thanks,
Chris

billg

Hey Stamey if this was an ironworker or pipe fitter site that would be like asking, what is the best oil or who makes the best tranny here.
When I was an ironworker (years ago) the Smith and Victors were the popular ones on the job site. I think the Smiths were a little tougher but both did a good job in the right hands. The biggest thing is having the right tips, right pressure for that tip, and a steady hand. If you are going to do just occasional shop work the Victor will do. If I remember correctly it is a little cheaper also and you will find tips and parts everywhere (or at least knock offs).
Good luck

beamhanger

ironworker here victor is better suited for me and i cut a lot of mis-fabricated discumbobulated steel. ive used smith also but i like victor the best

dodgedude361

NYC Ironworker here. my vote is for the Victor. They are tuffer, and much easier to clean.

The smith, if you work in a shop prolly would be better, thay are GREAT when new. But a little age, and that thing is junk .IMO.

I work in steel erection. Our torch is usually rolling around in the back of a truck, then thrown around the site. Lowered, and raised from floor to floor, to do some quick copeing of beams, or burning holes that weren`t punched. that victor takes a beating, just file the tip, stab the holes and yer ready to go


beamhanger, where do you work, are you UNION??