Other Everything else not covered in the main topics goes here. Please avoid brand and flame wars. Don't try and up your post count. It won't work in here.

Another reason not to drive the cummins through mud....(pics)

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 06-27-2009, 04:18 PM
  #31  
Registered User
 
HOHN's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Cummins Technical Center, IN
Posts: 6,564
Likes: 0
Received 6 Likes on 5 Posts
Originally Posted by wyododge06
Copehagenjunkie and j-fox you are exactly right about the land. I have been an avid wheeler for years and was always ****** when people would tare up the land. Stover tried his best to tread lightly and not contribute to more land damage by creating ruts and tearing up the grass. The people who were there when the truck first got stuck and then tried to get the truck out did a fair amount but, this is a well known area for people to go to and go mudding. It is a shame that they are so dumb and don’t care at all about the land.
Sounds like you guys need to stick the Weadawoo (or however the heck you spell it).

I had some safe fun out there in my truck.

JH
Old 06-27-2009, 09:23 PM
  #32  
Registered User
 
Spooler's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Claxton, GA
Posts: 5,902
Received 5 Likes on 4 Posts
Just like their are bad ATV, Jeep, and motorcycle guys, there are also bad horse folks who just don't care. So remember, it's always the one or two who ruin it for everyone. If you see them acting stupid then get them off the trails. If you have a group of horse folks, tell them where to ride and not to ride. If they can't obey, then byby to them too.
Old 06-30-2009, 01:23 PM
  #33  
Registered User
 
tool's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Posts: 1,524
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like on 1 Post
Originally Posted by bkrukow
I am one of those Quad guys. Unfortanatly the majorady of horse riders and hikers dont much like any of us and flat out dont wana share the trails with anyone but there own kind. Even if we are teh ones who created and maintain the trails. They want them for themselves. Funy thing is that a lot of the trails they are trying to close down or take over for there perpose where built buy either the Jeep groups or where old mining/loging roads that if not for the Jeeps/ATVS would not be maintained at all and would have grown over and disapered alltogether. I will admit that there are some young or irresponsible people on quads and Jeeps that ruin it for all of us. I personaly stay on the trail and you wont find me or anyone I ride with off in the middlel of a prarie ripping it up. If you consider knocking grass over destroying it then you need to go abck latter and look at it. Grass amazingly enough will poop back up shortly. I can understand the coment abought hoses causing damage to an extent but only to the same extent that an ATV will cause damage. If 1 horse goes over a wet spot 1 time the damage will be minimal but you may be able to see hoof marks in the mud, no long term damage worth mentioning. If 100 horses cross at the same place while its muddy then there will be significant damage, Ive seen it before but I dont go off half cocked telling everyone that horses are evil and should be baned from anywhere I see fit because somewhere some of them have caused damage to some dirt. Same holds true for ATVs. If I follow that horse threw the same mud or river crossing my tire tracks wont be any more significant than your horses trackes. Now if 100 more ATVs follow me then yes you will see a definate trail/rut in the mud. I can tell you from experiance that my ATV will float over softer ground with me on it than I can walk across and truthfully my feet will sink deeper into the mud than my tires will. I garontee that a horse that weighs several times more than an ATV will sink deeper into the soft ground then my ATV will. The PSI under a horses hoof has to be extreemly high compared to the ATV tire. If you figure there are 4 tires and mine are 12 inches wide and there is a contact pach aproxamtly 6 inches long. That comes out to just short of 300 square inches of ground contact. A ATV weighs 600 pounds plus driver. Thats a round 2PSI of ground presure. Now your horse weighs what?? For arguments sake I will guess 1500 pounds. Its hooves are what 6 inch diameter. when its walking its usaly on only 2 at a time. Thats 56 square inches of ground contact. Comes out to 26PSI. My point is that your horse is gona sink in ground and cause damage sooner than my ATV if we are both just cruising along and not deliberatly "spinning our tires 50 mph throwing huge roster tails of mud in the air". I dont condone ripping up public lands anymore than anyone else but to lump all people who would rather ride a Jeep or ATV into one group and say we all damage and wreck the trails is rediculos. I dont go bashing all horse riders saying that there pooping all over the nice clean enviroment and ruining it for all of time to come. No, your horses poop will adventualy disapere along with the hoofprints and our tire tracks.

Sory for the long winded, rambaling thoughts but this is a sore subject for a lot of us ATVers that practice the tread lightly and stay on the trail. We are loosing more and more very buitifull trails all over the country that a small handfull of idiouts have managed to ruin for the rest of us. The enviro nazies are reproducing in alarming rates. That combined with the small group of offroaders who do go where they dont belong and do damage pristien medows is making hard for the rest of us to have any fun.

I think your math is a little off.

First off the average saddle horse doesn't weigh anywhere near 1500#, my main horse is a big stout mare that I will rope and tie off onto mature cattle and she weighs about 1,100#. While many or even most horses you would see out riding a trail weigh in the 900-1,000# range. Plus at a walk a horse has three feet on the gound at once, not two.

While I would totally agree with you that ground pressure is less with an ATV I'm not too sure that the average contact patch would be 6" X 12" of course it would depend a lot on your tire size and air pressure, at a reasonable trail speed cyntrifical force is going to force that tire to be "round" a great deal more than when it is stopped (in which case maybe you contact patch is 6" long, bu I think that's generous)

Furthermore a Horse doesn't tread constantly like an ATV does and likely lands a foot down at approximate 36"- 48" or so at a slow walk I'd think? (that's only my best guess) At Faster gaits MUCH further apart. A horse going full bore has a stride length of close to 25'.

Furthermore there is much less slippage with a horse, it's wheel spin not ground pressure that causes dammage by a quad, especially when turning.

I am by no means somebody who hates quads or quad riders, I've ridden lots of quads lots of miles. My only point is that the notion that horses and trail riders causing more dammage then quads is asinine.

Go to you tube and look at the hundred of videos of quads tearing through holes and water and mud with huge Bearclaw tires and snorkel kits and then come back and tell me you see the same behaviour with horses.

A horse leaves no oil spills, burns no petro fuels, runs on grass, leaves only digested grass, is compostible or edible, emits next to no noise, (if you spent some time horseback you'd find that you can ride right up to wildlife and not disturb them, or you can watch deer and other wildlife scatter like crazy when you ride through with quads)

I'm by no means a "Greenie" or any of the rest of it but I can't help but roll my eyes back in my head listening to somebody say that horses are dammaging to trails and land in a greater way than motorised vehicles when I have a lifetime of first hand experince with both and know better than that.
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
BC847
Other
9
05-14-2011 05:33 PM
Dave88LX
Other
5
03-12-2006 09:51 PM
NJMurvin
3rd Generation Ram - Non Drivetrain - All Years
27
12-13-2005 01:02 AM
wagontrain131
Other
6
08-18-2004 04:48 AM
Copenhagenjunkie
24 Valve Engine and Drivetrain
2
12-27-2002 05:45 PM



Quick Reply: Another reason not to drive the cummins through mud....(pics)



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:32 AM.