To Idle Or not to Idle??
#1
To Idle Or not to Idle??
O.K. I have always been told that if you are just going to run into say a store or your house for a few minutes it is better to just let your truck idle because constant starts are hard on the starter.
Now I am hearing that idling is seriously bad for your truck.
It seems that every time my wife wants to go to the grocery store The little one falls asleep in the truck and I stay in the truck with her while the wife shops.
Should I idle or shut it off....
Now I am hearing that idling is seriously bad for your truck.
It seems that every time my wife wants to go to the grocery store The little one falls asleep in the truck and I stay in the truck with her while the wife shops.
Should I idle or shut it off....
#2
Idling is a two part deal.
1) It's good to idle so that EGT's cool down to a safe level before turning off.
2) It's bad to idle for very long periods of time because you will get cylinder wall washdown and a little fuel in your oil.
I believe I read somewhere that idling over 15 minutes is excessive, so with that in mind leave it run for 5 minutes while you run into the store for some coffee or beer, but shut it off or get a high idler if you are waiting in the parking lot for the Mrs. for an extended period of time.
1) It's good to idle so that EGT's cool down to a safe level before turning off.
2) It's bad to idle for very long periods of time because you will get cylinder wall washdown and a little fuel in your oil.
I believe I read somewhere that idling over 15 minutes is excessive, so with that in mind leave it run for 5 minutes while you run into the store for some coffee or beer, but shut it off or get a high idler if you are waiting in the parking lot for the Mrs. for an extended period of time.
#3
Registered User
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Beaverton, Oregon
Posts: 1,915
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Be mindfull of the state that you are in. Check your local laws, some states and or cities state it is against the law to let a vehichle idle while you run into the store. Yo could a) get it stolen or b) get it towed and get a big ticket
#6
Registered User
Personally, I wouldn't worry about it. Let it run if you want to. Shut it down if you want to. It's a machine.....it doesn't care and it doesn't have feelings.
I don't intentionally let my truck idle and idle.....but if im stopped somewhere and need A/C etc.....I keep myself comfortable and let it run.
Honestly I don't think idling hurts them. Big rigs do it all night long.
If cylinder "wash down" does exist.........I have never seen any documented proof of Cummins engine damage due to it on this board or any other source. I'd welcome somebody to prove me wrong and show me the evidence or a link to it.
I don't intentionally let my truck idle and idle.....but if im stopped somewhere and need A/C etc.....I keep myself comfortable and let it run.
Honestly I don't think idling hurts them. Big rigs do it all night long.
If cylinder "wash down" does exist.........I have never seen any documented proof of Cummins engine damage due to it on this board or any other source. I'd welcome somebody to prove me wrong and show me the evidence or a link to it.
#7
Originally Posted by Homer S.
If the little one's asleep, do whatever you have to to keep em that way. May have to drive laps around the parking lot.
I have done more laps around parking lots than I can count !!!
Trending Topics
#10
Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Southern NH
Posts: 306
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There was a long post here about 6 months ago on the subject.
I believe the concern with these new motors is due to the injectors. With mechanical injection, like big rigs, they can idle all night. I think the new injectors run into problems when squirting little fuel for long periods.... but that’s only my recollection.
I believe the concern with these new motors is due to the injectors. With mechanical injection, like big rigs, they can idle all night. I think the new injectors run into problems when squirting little fuel for long periods.... but that’s only my recollection.
#11
idling
I work out of my truck so it idles all day long. I was told as long as your engine temp stays up so that your fuel burns, your allright. I use the cruise control to idle my truck up to 1100 RPM. I know guys that do the same type of work that have more idle time than driving time on thier trucks and I havent heard of anyone having trouble. I think that it is hard on your tranny because it doesnt lubricate unless you have work done or replace your valve body.
#12
Originally Posted by fozzy777
I use the cruise control to idle my truck up to 1100 RPM.
#13
Registered User
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Alexandria,Virgina
Posts: 145
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by fozzy777
I work out of my truck so it idles all day long. I was told as long as your engine temp stays up so that your fuel burns, your allright. I use the cruise control to idle my truck up to 1100 RPM. I know guys that do the same type of work that have more idle time than driving time on thier trucks and I havent heard of anyone having trouble. I think that it is hard on your tranny because it doesnt lubricate unless you have work done or replace your valve body.
After I read your post i went out to my truck and tried to set the cruise controll on my truck at 1100 rpm. It won't set I tried diferant things to see if it would set with the door closed and my seat belt on and even in gear(automatic). No luck, is there someting else that I need to do to set the cruise higher while I'm parked?
#14
Registered User
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Jeffersonville, Ohio
Posts: 3,604
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by TexasCTD
Honestly I don't think idling hurts them. Big rigs do it all night long.
If cylinder "wash down" does exist.........I have never seen any documented proof of Cummins engine damage due to it on this board or any other source. I'd welcome somebody to prove me wrong and show me the evidence or a link to it.
If cylinder "wash down" does exist.........I have never seen any documented proof of Cummins engine damage due to it on this board or any other source. I'd welcome somebody to prove me wrong and show me the evidence or a link to it.
The problem with idling you're Cummins, is not so much wash down (at least not with stock injectors), but your 24v can get "cold" EGT's, and begin to build up carbon on the valves. If enough builds up, it can bend pushrods. Not a common failure, but not unheard of either!!
Bottom line, you can leave it idle for a few minutes, but beyond that, idle it up...at least 11-1200RPM! That keeps everything buning right where it should be
Chris
Besides, don't you CR guys have that Cruise Control high idler??? Cheaters...I have to use a stick
#15
Registered User
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Batavia, Ohio
Posts: 1,570
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by bamataco1
After I read your post i went out to my truck and tried to set the cruise controll on my truck at 1100 rpm. It won't set I tried diferant things to see if it would set with the door closed and my seat belt on and even in gear(automatic). No luck, is there someting else that I need to do to set the cruise higher while I'm parked?
the dealer has to enable it. It is a TSB. it's for the complaint of rough idle and slow warm up. It is a nice option, i use it all the time